The power of "real identity" & "discovery": How Facebook can break into the markets of Craigslist and Ebay
By Naren Reddy
(AXcess News) - Facebook is moving to position itself as the hub of all interest based communities (Pinterest, Spotify, Foodspotting, and Goodreads for example) with its OpenGraph platform. The people we follow in these networks are not necessarily our friends, but people whose content ‘interests' us. At the end of the day, all these communities are peer to peer. Facebook can re-imagine two big peer-to-peer markets with Real identity, Discovery and Imitation enabled by the OpenGraph at the center
Reimagining the classifieds market
The classifieds marketplace is currently being cannibalized by services that operate in vertical niches.Here are list of few businesses which have been cannibalizing Craigslist
-- airbnb, roomorama, 9flats [ sublets/temporary section]
-- zillow, trulia [realestate section]
-- dogvacay [petservices section]
-- indeed, simplyhired [jobs section]
-- sittingaround [childcare section]
and so on..
The problem for anyone starting a new classifieds site on the web is two-fold:
1) Getting the people who have the need [e.g., apartment searchers]
2) Getting people to serve the need [e.g., people who want to rent out apartments]
In short, the problem is discovery.
Facebook is very good at discovery and with 1 billion users - half of whom log in everyday - it is in a unique position to partner with niche companies and bring their listings together to form a full-fledged classifieds site.
The listings on a Facebook classifieds site could be populated by:
i) Its partners (Airbnb, Taskrabbit, Etsy etc)
ii) Facebook users who submit listings on to the site directly
On the classifieds site, Facebook could take a cut out of every night booked, every task completed, every caretaker's service requested, every service requested from a lawyer, for every job applied, for every gadget sold, etc.
Services like Airbnb, LegalZoom, Gazelle could push all their listings data to Facebook happily because this will help them promote their services to 1 billion+ people, instead of them having to spend millions of dollars on marketing.
Facebook can innovate heavily in the way they source the listings data, bypassing the middlemen.With the data Facebook already has, it can personalize the listings data heavily (an engineer will be shown just the engineering jobs around him and not the sales jobs)
Facebook can launch the classified service as a separate property, then integrate it with Facebook so users can access the service directly from his Facebook homepage and navigate through it seamlessly.
Making use of the FacebookConnect
Services like Airbnb have integrated the FacebookConnect plugin as their primary login. Only people who have logged in to 3rd party sites using FacebookConnect can be allowed to push their listings to Facebook classifieds site as this will help put "true identity" & "trust of dealing with a real name" at the center of all the transactions that happens inside the classifieds network.
Classifieds market currently is massively under served and can be compared to mobile phone market prior to the launch of the iPhone. The individual markets like properties for rent, used cars, home services, and jobs are each their own billion dollar business. The revenues of Facebook Classifieds site will depend on how innovatively the listings can be sourced and the overall execution of the platform.
Putting Trust at the Center of All Transactions in the Peer-to-Peer Marketplace
Imagine a link on your Facebook homepage which takes you to a page with products listed categorically, posted by other Facebook users and waiting to be sold.With the real names and the personal identity information Facebook has, it can facilitate transactions more reliably than other other peer to peer buy/sell markets out there.With its social graph data, Facebook could quickly weed out scammers who form closed groups and write fake reviews from multiple profiles.
Other networks that facilitate online transactions do not have the same kind of personally identifiable and communication data that Facebook can rely on (communication data can help Facebook come up with a trust score for people who plan on selling/buying on the site for the first time without any history.) The communication data Facebook has makes it the primary competitive advantage.
An average American family has about $7,000+ worth of unused stuff.Women make most of the purchase decisions in the household. With the imitation enabled by Open Graph, Facebook can help women list all the unused stuff in their household.This market will be bigger than the market currently served by Ebay.
Facebook can create two new brands (www.four.com - classifieds site & www.fbiz.com - buy/sell site) for offering these services and integrate them deeply into the main site to prevent brand dilution (and goal dilution). Before Facebook implements these changes it needs a profile redesign with third party interest based networks at the center.
Nobody owns the market. eBay doesn't own the peer-to-peer buy/sell market. Craigslist doesn't own the classifieds market. Google doesn't own the search engine market. They just serve the market. If somebody comes along with a product which can serve the market better, the market responds. In the technology industry where change happens rapidly, Craigslist and eBay are ripe for an unseating.
Source: Naren Reddy is the Chief Product Officer at Wignite, whose products include wisiRecruit, a social media recruiting tool for colleges and wisiPlan, an eILP tool. Follow him on Twitter at @naren.